Open Collaborative Research Proposals

Jean-Claude Bradley's picture

As an indicator of the trends of Open Science and crowdsourcing, initiatives are arising to facilitate collaboration for the purpose of seeking research funding. For example, the SCIEnCE project (1) serves as a repository for such open proposals:

SCIEnCE – Share Collaborative Ideas, Enact Cooperative Efforts – is part of the growing movement dedicated to encouraging public sharing of testable ideas. Not just ideas, but plans of action – ideas will be developed into specific, step-by-step proposals via Wiki-inspired community editing. A new system for attributing credit will be used to distribute funding for SCIEnCE projects. The projects outlined by these collaboratively written proposals will be tackled with a cooperative experimental approach.

In order to fully capitalize on the benefits of such a strategy, the involvement of funding agencies will be necessary. This may only happen when a critical mass of proposals and people is reached.

Discussions about how new funding mechanisms could be established to take advantage of such a system are currently taking place (2). Cameron Neylon writes:

What is being generated here is new science, and science isn’t paid for per se. The resources that generate science are supported by governments, charities, and industry but the actual production of science is not supported. The truly radical approach to this would be to turn the system on its head. Don’t fund the universities to do science, fund the journals to buy science; then the system would reward increased efficiency. As it exists at the moment the funding system does nothing to support increased efficiency.

In stock exchanges and money markets, people are paid an awfully large amount of money to make what are fundamentally rather simple connections between buyers and sellers. This is still, for the most part, ultimately handled by humans, although there is a move towards fully automatic position taking. The connections we are talking about are much more complex to understand. To make this work we need to figure out how to reward the people who can make those connections. We also need to find a way to put money into the system to actually help provide the additional resources required to actually make things happen.

Tags:

Average: 4 (2 votes)

Hypotheses that reference this signal:

This signal has no hypotheses. Add a hypothesis

Forecasts that reference this signal:

This signal has no forecasts. Add a forecast